Voluntary trading update, trading statement and renewal of cautionary announcement
Phumelela Gaming and Leisure Limited
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa)
(Registration number: 1997/016610/06)
Share Code: PHM ISIN: ZAE000039269
Voluntary trading update, trading statement and renewal of cautionary announcement
Voluntary trading update
Phumelela Gaming and Leisure Limited (“Group”) has made it clear in previous communications to
shareholders that trading conditions during the 2018 financial year and during the first half of the 2019
financial year were very difficult and were not expected to improve. The Group revealed to shareholders
at the interim results presentation practical interventions to deliver long-term cost savings and to
restructure for commercial realities. Furthermore, the removal of the Group’s 50% share of the 6% levy
on punters’ winnings on fixed-odds bets on horseracing has had an adverse financial effect on the
Phumelela was entitled to this levy in terms of Regulation 276 of the Gauteng Gambling Regulations,
1997, which the Member of the Executive Council responsible for Economic Development,
Environment, Agriculture and Rural Development (“the MEC”) elected to amend to revoke Phumelela’s
entitlement to a share of the levy. Shareholders are reminded that the Group is trading under cautionary
in respect of an application to have the amendment of Regulation 276 reviewed and set aside. The
most recent cautionary announcement is dated 4 June 2019.
The results for the six months ended 31 January 2019 reflected a considerable deterioration in trading
conditions in local tote and fixed odds operations whilst the local losses on horseracing operations have
increased. Despite international profits, the total loss in Media Operations increased by 35%. An interim
dividend was not declared in order to conserve cash. The results presentation concluded that “it is
impossible to give certainty on trading results for the full year”. Circumstances post the publication of
the half-year results on 29 March 2019 are worse than anticipated, exacerbated by the withholding of
the levy by the Gauteng Government as a result of the amendment to Regulation 276.
Given the above backdrop of uncertainty, and in view of the fact that annual results for the twelve
months ended 31 July 2019 are only scheduled to be published on or about 4 October 2019, the Board,
in the interests of continuing candid communication with shareholders, believes it is necessary to advise
on the situation post the interim results and with respect to guidance for the full year results.
In South Africa, Betting Operations comprise over-the-counter (“OTC”) retail outlets and non-OTC,
being internet and telephone betting. Phumelela brands include Betting World and Tab whilst the Group
has a 50% interest in Supabets and has a JV with Supabets in Supaworld Proprietary Limited, a
company jointly owned by Betting World and Supabets.
As communicated at the half-year results, there are active interventions to rationalise and optimise the
tote and fixed-odds operations. The costs of right-sizing fall within the 2019 financial year.
The permanent annual cash savings in the rationalised Betting World/Tab is estimated at R60 million,
which will benefit the 2020 financial year and give significant relief to the Group’s financial position.
Whilst there has been growth in total betting turnover for the ten months to 31 May 2019, the mix of the
business has changed, with a switch in betting from the tote to fixed odds, where margin is lower. Across
tote and fixed odds, the combined betting income margin is 1.9 percentage points lower than for the
same period ended 31 May 2018 with fixed odds the most affected. Profits this year are also affected
by the 1% increase in VAT in April 2018.
Although Supabets had a poor March and May, the business remains profitable but is anticipated to
end the year with a reduced profit. The Supaworld JV footprint is growing with Betting World licenses
being deployed as Supabets mega outlets where average turnovers are higher. Supaworld also had a
poor March and May and remains marginally profitable.
Interbet, the local online betting exchange in which the Group has a 50% interest, has continued to
perform well, and year-to-date is recording single-digit growth, which in a depressed consumer
environment is very pleasing.
The Group also records equity-accounted income from the jointly owned Premier Gateway International
tote operator on the Isle of Man, included in the non-OTC segment. This business returned an excellent
result for the first half and is projected to end the year with double-digit growth.
Despite Supabets recording a lower profit for the ten-month period, total profits from equity accounted
associates was higher in real terms.
Media Operations comprise the selling of media and data rights of South African horseracing locally
and internationally and includes the administration of horseracing.
The horseracing operations remain loss-making on a stand-alone basis. This has been the case for
several years, with losses increasing each year.
The loss-making position has been made worse by the removal of the 3% levy due to Phumelela in
terms of Regulation 276, as earlier referred to. The payment of this levy forms part of the agreement
between the Gauteng Government and the racing industry and is intended to ensure the sustainability
of horseracing. Phumelela must shoulder the costs in horseracing but income from other sources is
insufficient to make up for the costs. The 3% levy has been withheld with effect from 1 April 2019 and
deprives Phumelela of over R6 million on average per month in income.
Legal Matters and related
Further to detailed disclosure on legal matters in the first-half results, the following are pertinent.
As discussed above, the MEC amended the Gauteng Gambling Regulations with effect from 1 April
2019. Shareholders are referred to public disclosure in this regard as published via the Stock Exchange
News Service and as updated in the financial results for the six months ended 31 January 2019.
The Group lodged papers on 21 June 2019 in the North Gauteng High Court to have the Public
Protector’s report into thoroughbred horseracing in Gauteng set aside on the basis that the findings of
the Public Protector in the report are unlawful, irrational, unreasonable and unconstitutional.
It is further noted that the Gauteng Gambling Board (“the Board”) and the MEC filed a separate
application, on 8 July 2019, to have the public Protector’s report (alternatively the remedial action)
reviewed and set aside and to have the report remitted to the Public Protector for reconsideration.
The Group intends to lodge papers in the High Court to have the decision by the Gauteng Gambling
Board to find it guilty of contravening condition 10 of its Gauteng Race-Meeting licence reviewed and
set aside. The Board imposed a fine of R5 million, of which R2.5 million has been suspended for 5
years and directed Phumelela to apply to it for the approval of its broadcasting fees.
Given the reduced profitability and withholding of the 3% levy, that has been received for over twenty
years, the Group finds itself in a challenging situation. An accrual of approximately R26 million is
necessary in the 2019 financial year due to the income from the bookmaker levy not being paid since 1
April 2019, with an annual impact of approximately R75 million.
The Group is therefore in breach of covenants in respect of its R300 million in borrowings. Phumelela’s
financial executives are in regular contact with banking executives to keep them apprised of
developments within the business.
No interim dividend was paid, and the Group is in no position to pay a final dividend.
Cash conservation is of the utmost priority as is cutting our coat according to the diminished cloth
available. At the half-year, the Group reported that Directors are cognisant of the fact that the results
have been poor, that funding headroom has been exhausted, and that all measures necessary to
stabilise the position must be taken. Shareholders should be aware that the Board see no positive relief
from external factors anytime soon and that internal remedial measures are the only option.
For the ten month period to 31 May 2019, cash utilised by operations, payment of the final gross cash
dividend declared for the 2018 financial year, together with capital expenditure, was funded and covered
by dividends received from equity accounted investees and asset sales, which included a property and
shares in ASL in Mauritius. A further asset sale is under negotiation and the Group is seeking a fair
A provision of R20 million has been made for current right-sizing initiatives.
Capex is under scrutiny. Whilst we subscribe to prudent spending to ensure a competitive estate, recent
negative events mean we must economise in order to be able to maintain necessary capex in future.
The Group is fortunate to have strong international cash flows and profits, which in the year to 31 July
2018 amounted to R204,3 million and which for the six months ended 31 January 2019 amounted to
However, it is important to bear in mind that a considerable proportion of international income is a
function of Phumelela in South Africa being able to put up the show and ensure a world-class racing
product for international punters. Should the local operations be in jeopardy, and that includes the
betting operations, the domino effect through the entire horseracing value chain would be disastrous, it
would destroy an already fragile industry and eliminate international income. It is therefore imperative
to take all steps necessary to ensure that we navigate this unprecedented turbulence to keep the show
Total assets have a carrying value of R1.7 billion, of which R0.7 billion represents equity accounted
investees, including Supabets and Interbet. Equity is at R985 million. Net gearing to total equity is 30%
and net gearing to tangible net asset value is approximately 40%.
In view of the reduced profitability and the withholding of the 3% levy, the carrying value of assets may
have to be reassessed. The deferred taxation asset may have to be impaired.
Permanent annual cash savings of R60 million from the rationalisation of Betting World/Tab, immediate
steps taken to focus on restoring fixed odds margins, and measures to economise on capex, will relieve
the financial position and address the short-term cash deficit.
Restructuring options for the horseracing industry
As mentioned in the half-year commentary, the Board remains open to any realistic and constructive
ideas that may benefit horseracing and the shareholders of Phumelela.
The Group has reopened the conceptual discussions that were terminated last year and is presently
engaging with key stakeholders in the horseracing industry to examine scope for cooperation,
consolidation, and pooling of financial resources. All feasible scenarios are on the table. Shareholders
will be kept informed when we have concrete information to convey.
The Board does not have the required degree of certainty to provide shareholders with detail of the
anticipated range expected for earnings per share and headline earnings per share for the year
ending 31 July 2019. The Board does have the required degree of certainty that earnings per share
and headline earnings per share will be below those of the previous year by more than 20%, hence
this trading statement. With ten months of the financial year behind the Group and given the
deterioration in income and profitability subsequent to the interim period, together with substantial
restructuring costs, it is inevitable that the Group will report a loss for the year.
As and when the Board has the required degree of certainty to provide a further update on this trading
statement, it will do so without delay.
The financial information contained in this voluntary trading update and trading statement has not
been reviewed or reported upon by the Group’s external auditors.
Renewal of cautionary announcement
Further to the announcement dated 4 June 2019, the Company remains under cautionary as
engagements with the Gauteng Member of the Executive Council responsible for Economic
Development, Environment, Agriculture and Rural Development (“the MEC”) and the Gauteng
Gambling Board are still in progress.
Shareholders are advised to continue exercising caution when dealing in the Company’s securities
until a further announcement is made.
12 July 2019
Sponsor: Investec Bank
Date: 12/07/2019 03:58:00 Produced by the JSE SENS Department. The SENS service is an information dissemination service administered by the JSE Limited ('JSE').
The JSE does not, whether expressly, tacitly or implicitly, represent, warrant or in any way guarantee the truth, accuracy or completeness of
the information published on SENS. The JSE, their officers, employees and agents accept no liability for (or in respect of) any direct,
indirect, incidental or consequential loss or damage of any kind or nature, howsoever arising, from the use of SENS or the use of, or reliance on,
information disseminated through SENS.
Email this JSE Sens Item to a Friend.