To view the PDF file, sign up for a MySharenet subscription.

Sanlam Group - Interim Results for the six months ended 30 June 2005

Release Date: 08/09/2005 08:00
Code(s): SLM
Wrap Text

Sanlam Group - Interim Results for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Sanlam Group Registered name: Sanlam Limited (Registration number 1959/001562/06) JSE share code: SLM NSX share code: SLA ISIN number: ZAE000028262 Interim Results for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Key features Earnings - Headline earnings per share up 85% - Core earnings per share up 18% Business Flows - Total new business inflows up 11% to R30 billion - Investment inflows up 14% to R20,8 billion - Net funds inflow of R495 million Embedded Value - Embedded value of 1 441 cents per share - Annualised return on embedded value 23,2% - Embedded value of new life business R114 million - New business embedded value margin 12,4% SALIENT FEATURES for the six months ended 30 June 2005 2005 2004 % SANLAM LIMITED GROUP Earnings: Result from financial services after R million 1 006 848 19% tax Core earnings (1) R million 1 556 1 251 24% Headline earnings (2) R million 2 681 1 384 94% Adjusted headline earnings based on R million 2 250 1 882 20% the LTRR (3) Net result from financial services cents 38,5 34,0 13% per share Core earnings per share (1) cents 59,4 50,2 18% Headline earnings per share (2) cents 102,5 55,5 85% Adjusted headline earnings per share cents 86,0 75,5 14% based on the LTRR (3) Group administration cost ratio (4) % 28,3 31,6 Group operating margin (5) % 20,1 20,8 Business volumes: New business volumes R million 30 134 27 143 11% Net fund flows R million 495 8 263 Value of new life business R million 114 133 -14% Life insurance new business APE (6) R million 919 917 Value of new business margin (7) % 12,4 14,5 Embedded value: Embedded value R million 39 263 30 481 29% Embedded value per share cents 1 441 1 114 29% Growth from life business % 16,6 16,1 Return on embedded value (8) % 23,2 11,5 SANLAM LIFE INSURANCE LIMITED Shareholders" fund R million 27 555 19 877 39% Capital adequacy requirements (CAR) R million 6 250 7 775 20% CAR covered by prudential capital times 3,8 2,4 58% Notes (1) Core earnings = net result from financial services and net investment income (including dividends received from associates). (2) Headline earnings = core earnings, net investment surpluses, secondary tax on companies and equity-accounted headline earnings less dividends received from associates. (3) Adjusted headline earnings based on the LTRR = net result from financial services and total investment return based on a long-term rate of return. (4) Administration costs as a percentage of financial services income earned by the shareholders" fund less sales remuneration. (5) Result from financial services as a percentage of financial services income earned by the shareholders" fund less sales remuneration. (6) APE = annual premium equivalent and is equal to new recurring premiums (excluding indexed growth premiums) plus 10% of single premiums. (7) Value of new business margin = value of new business as a percentage of life insurance new business APE. (8) Growth in embedded value (with dividends paid, capital raised and cost of treasury shares acquired reversed) as a percentage of embedded value at the beginning of the period. (9) Returns for 6 months are annualised. (10) Extracted from IFRS segmental information, except for embedded value results. EXECUTIVE REVIEW Overall performance These results are the first to be presented based on International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). Headline earnings for the six months to June 2005 amounted to R2 681 million, a 94% improvement on the first half of 2004. Headline earnings per share improved by 85% to 102,5 cps. The strong equity markets experienced during the period largely contributed to this growth. The net result from financial services for the first six months of 2005 increased by 19% on 2004. As expected, Santam experienced some contraction in its underwriting results during the period. This detracted somewhat from an otherwise satisfactory financial performance across the Group. An improvement of 36% in net investment income contributed to an overall improvement in Core earnings of 24% to R1 556 million. New business volumes were 11% higher than in the first half of 2004, primarily due to an increase in retail and multi manager asset management investment inflows. Total investments under management increased by 29% to R375 billion during the period. New life insurance business flows were down 3% on the comparable period in 2004 as the recent negative sentiment towards life insurers contributed to a deteriorating environment for contractual savings and life insurance products in particular. The embedded value of new life business for the period amounted to R114 million, which is 14% lower than in the corresponding period in 2004. The annualised return on embedded value increased to 23,2% in the first half of 2005, which is well in excess of our hurdle rate. Delivering on strategy Major progress has been made in 2005 on Sanlam"s strategy to grow a more balanced business within a defined financial services framework and to create an optimal capital structure for the Group: - An important milestone has been the disposal of the Sanlam shareholders" fund"s entire holding of 124 million shares in Absa to Barclays Plc for some R10 billion in July 2005. This transaction removed an imbalance in Sanlam"s capital portfolio and released capital for alternative application. It created the liquidity necessary to redeploy capital of approximately R7 billion that the Board regards as excess to the Group"s current capital requirement. - In July 2005 Sanlam announced that the Board proposed a reduction in capital of approximately R4 billion. This proposal is expected to be effected by a simultaneous specific pro rata repurchase of shares from all shareholders and a voluntary offer to shareholders holding a small number of shares, followed by a share repurchase in the open market. A circular with full details on the proposal has been distributed to shareholders. A special shareholder meeting has been convened for 21 September to obtain the required shareholder approval to implement this process. - In May 2005 Sanlam announced its entry into the Indian insurance market in partnership with the local Shriram group. This is a unique opportunity for Sanlam to explore this potentially lucrative market with a fairly limited initial capital outlay. The partnership is in line with our strategy of developing selective international opportunities with the potential to diversify revenue and enhance profitability on a sustainable basis. - During August 2005 Sanlam announced a firm intention to acquire all of the issued ordinary shares of African Life Assurance Company Limited ("African Life") for some R2.6 billion as well as a controlling interest in Channel Life for some R116 million. We have identified the entry-level life insurance market as an important component of our growth strategy. The acquisition of African Life, as well as the investment in Channel Life, will provide Sanlam with a meaningful presence from which to consolidate and accelerate our existing offering through Sanlam Group Solutions and Safrican in this segment. These are revenue-enhancing acquisitions that we are confident will improve our earnings, new business embedded value and return on embedded value. The offer for African Life still needs to be accepted by a requisite majority of African Life shareholders and sanctioned by the court to become effective. Both transactions are also subject to obtaining the necessary regulatory approvals. Sanlam is committed to providing a competitive value offering to all our clients and is continuously seeking ways to improve this. To this end, Sanlam Life has introduced a new product solution that provides retirement annuities and endowments with materially improved values when a policy is paid up, surrendered, or when premium reductions are made. It provides for improved values on retirement annuities and endowments from the very first month of the policy"s existence. The Pension Fund Adjudicator The Pension Fund Adjudicator recently issued a number of rulings that could have potentially significant implications for Sanlam and the insurance industry as a whole. Sanlam strongly supports actions to ensure the equitable treatment of policyholders. It is in the interest of our policyholders and shareholders that all parties honour the contractual, regulatory and legal framework upon which the life insurance industry was founded. It is on this basis that we have decided to institute the necessary legal processes to appeal against the Adjudicator"s rulings. We are awaiting the outcome of this process. Due to the uncertainty of the cost, if any, involved in addressing the potential claims raised by the Adjudicator"s rulings, no specific provision has been created for this purpose in the financial statements and embedded value. Looking forward The Board and management remain focused on delivering on four key strategic areas: - achieving growth through a product and distribution capability that is aligned with Sanlam"s targeted markets; - further improving operational efficiencies to ensure long-term profitability while improving the value proposition for our clients; - continued emphasis on capital optimisation; and - accelerating Sanlam"s brand positioning through transformation and marketing. The buoyant equity markets had a significant impact on the strong headline earnings reported for the first six months of 2005. This trend may not continue during the second half of the year, given the direct impact of equity markets on headline earnings growth. Second half performance will also be impacted by the sale of the investment in Absa. A substantial component of the proceeds from the sale has been invested in liquid assets in anticipation of the share buy back programme and the settlement of the African Life acquisition. The benefits of the acquisition of African Life and the capital reduction will contribute to performance from 2006. Roy Andersen Johan van Zyl Chairman Group Chief Executive Sanlam Limited Cape Town 7 September 2005 COMMENTS ON THE INTERIM RESULTS TO JUNE 2005 International Financial Reporting Standards The Sanlam group results, as presented for the six months to 30 June have been prepared, for the first time, based on and in compliance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). Both the interim and full year 2004 results have been restated accordingly. The global development and practical interpretation and application of these accounting standards are however ongoing and certain interpretations and disclosures adopted in these interim results may be subject to change in future reports. While we fully support the efforts of the accounting profession to achieve consistency in reporting and to counter any misrepresentation of company results, we are concerned that the current implementation of IFRS may not in all instances reflect economic and contractual reality; the most notable examples being the prescribed IFRS valuation bases of investments in subsidiaries, associated companies and Sanlam Limited shares supporting policy liabilities. We will continue to interact with all role players to find an appropriate approach to these problem areas. Earnings Shareholders" fund summarised income statement for the six months ended 30 June 2005 R million 2005 2004 % Net result from financial services 1 006 848 19% Net investment income 550 403 36% CORE EARNINGS 1 556 1 251 24% Secondary Tax on Companies (STC) (87) - Net investment surpluses 791 (208) Return on shareholders" fund 700 (118) Fund transfers 91 (90) Equity-accounted headline earnings 421 341 23% HEADLINE EARNINGS 2 681 1 384 94% Other equity-accounted earnings (8) (12) Net discontinuance costs - (13) Loss on disposal of subsidiary (4) - Impairment of investments and goodwill 6 (16) Attributable earnings 2 675 1 343 99% Net result from financial services 1 006 848 19% Net investment return 1 669 495 Attributable earnings 2 675 1 343 99% Net result from financial services and 919 848 8% STC LTRR investment return 1 331 1 034 29% LTRR HEADLINE EARNINGS 2 250 1 882 20% The comments on the results are based on an analysis of the IFRS income statement in a management-reporting format. A reconciliation with the IFRS income statement is provided in the financial statements. Headline Earnings Headline earnings of R2 681 million are up 94% and Headline earnings per share of 102.5 cents are up 85% on the first six months of 2004. The lower per share level of increase on 2004 is due to an increase in the number of issued shares, essentially following the implementation of the Ubuntu-Botho (UB) empowerment transaction in April 2004. Following the introduction of IFRS and the designation of all shareholders" fund investments as "at fair value through profit or loss", Headline earnings now include all fair value changes on the investments held by the shareholders" fund. This introduced significant volatility into Headline earnings, as is evidenced by the sharp increase in Headline earnings over the prior period, substantially due to relatively higher equity market growth during the first six months of 2005. In determining the Sanlam group results Sanlam shares held in the policyholder portfolios now have to be treated as treasury shares (and no longer as an investment at fair value) and shares held by these portfolios in Santam (subsidiary), Vukile (subsidiary), Satrix (consolidated fund) and Absa (associated company up to 30 June 2005) may no longer be accounted for as investments at fair value, but must be accounted for at their net asset value and equity-accounted values respectively. As a consequence, a transfer (through Headline earnings) is required to or from the shareholders" fund in respect of the market value changes of these shares. For the six months to June 2005, this transfer to the shareholders" fund amounted to R91 million, compared to a transfer from the shareholders" fund of R90 million for the same period in 2004. Excluding these transfers the growth in headline earnings amounts to 76%. Headline earnings are reported after a Secondary Tax on Companies (STC) charge of R87 million in respect of Sanlam"s 2004 dividend paid in May 2005. This follows the first time recognition in the 2004 results of a deferred tax asset in respect of unused STC credits. After the adoption of IFRS, there is little difference between Attributable earnings and Headline earnings, except that goodwill impairments are included in Attributable earnings but do not form part of Headline earnings. LTRR Earnings Earnings based on a long-term rate of investment return (LTRR) are 20% higher than for the first six months of 2004, mainly due to the higher asset base on which the long-term return is calculated. The asset base benefited from the higher market values due to the strong growth towards the end of 2004 and in 2005 as well as the UB proceeds received in April 2004. The long-term return rate used has been lowered from 11% to 10% for 2005. Core Earnings A Sanlam Core earnings figure is presented in an attempt to provide shareholders with an indication of `normalised" earnings. Core earnings comprise the net result from financial services and net investment income earned on the shareholders" fund and exclude certain items that may cause volatility in headline earnings, including changes in market value of the investments in the shareholders" fund and transfers to or from the policyholders" fund. To ensure consistency in our approach Core earnings no longer account for all the equity- accounted earnings of non-operating companies, but only account for dividends received from these associated companies. On this basis, Core earnings of R1 556 million are 24% up on 2004, reflecting a 19% growth in the net result from financial services and a 36% increase in investment income. The latter consists of dividends and interest earned on the shareholders" fund, as well as the margin earned on the Group"s preference share portfolio, and has been largely impacted by the higher Absa dividend received in the current reporting period. The growth in the net result from financial services reflects an improved performance by all Group operations, with the exception, as anticipated, of a contraction in Santam"s performance. Gross of tax and minority interests the result from financial services of R1 573 million is 6% higher than in 2004. The taxation charge for the six-month period (as well as for 2004) is net of the utilisation of taxation losses that emanated from a historical tax dispensation. As indicated in the 2004 annual report this will be substantially utilised by the end of the 2005 financial year. Result from financial services for the six months ended 30 June R million 2005 2004 % Life insurance 777 704 10% Sanlam Personal Finance 685 628 9% Sanlam Employee Benefits 92 76 21% Short-term insurance 532 663 (20%) Investment management 269 208 29% Sanlam Capital Markets 51 49 4% Independent Financial Services 26 30 (13%) Corporate expenses (82) (81) (1%) Continued operations 1 573 1 573 - Discontinued operations - (94) - Gross result from financial 1 573 1 479 6% services - The Life insurance cluster recorded a 10% improvement to R777 million in its results for the six months. The major contributor to the cluster"s performance, Sanlam Personal Finance, increased its contribution by 9% to R685 million. This can be attributed to buoyant stock markets, which improved underlying asset values and fees earned, favourable risk underwriting experience and the containment of administration expenses. Sanlam Employee Benefits benefited from a favourable risk underwriting experience and increased its contribution by 21% to R92 million. - The short-term insurance industry recorded unprecedented underwriting results in 2003 and 2004. As expected these could not be sustained indefinitely and the margins achieved came under pressure in the first six months of 2005. Santam"s net insurance result for the period of R532 million is down by 20% on 2004. - The results of the Investment cluster for the six-month period increased to R269 million, a 29% improvement on the corresponding period in 2004. The international businesses in the cluster made a large contribution to this increase, notwithstanding a stronger Rand, with Sanlam Multi Manager International (SMMI) continuing to extract margin benefits from its growing asset base. The transfer of Merchant Investors Assurance (MIA) investments to SMMI contributed to the growth in asset base, crystallising the synergies anticipated with the acquisition of MIA. Octane also had a very successful first half of 2005. The South African investment management businesses increased their profits by some 11%, with Sanlam Private Investments and Sanlam Collective Investments in particular recording strong growth in earnings. - Sanlam Capital Markets" contribution of R51 million is 4% up on 2004 and in line with expectations. - The contribution from Independent Financial Services is down by 13% to R26 million, substantially due to the sale of 65% of Gensec Property Services in the second half of 2004. Total Group administration expenses for the six months were marginally lower than in 2004, resulting in an improvement in the overall administration expense ratio from 31.6% to 28.3%. Business volumes New business flows Total new business inflows of R30 billion for the six months are 11% higher than for the corresponding period in 2004. Strong growth from the Sanlam Multi- Manager and retail investment inflows are somewhat offset by lower segregated fund inflows at Sanlam Investment Management (SIM) and some reduction in SFS UK inflows. Santam"s net premium income rose by 15%. New Business Volumes for the six months ended 30 June R million 2005 2004 % Individual single 3 426 3 604 (5%) Individual recurring 717 687 4% Group business 1 064 1 076 (1%) Life business 5 207 5 367 (3%) Investment cluster 14 064 12 040 17% Innofin 3 058 3 148 (3%) SFS UK 2 539 2 730 (7%) Namibia Unit Trust 1 127 274 >100% Investment business 20 788 18 192 14% Short-term insurance 4 139 3 584 15% TOTAL 30 134 27 143 11% The low interest rates of late, coupled with the recent negative press reports on the insurance industry, impacted client investment behaviour and negatively affected life insurance business volumes as private and collective investments grew in popularity as substitutes for insurance policy based investments. Individual Life new recurring premiums grew by 4% for the six months but single premiums were down 5% on 2004, substantially due to a fall in life policy continuations and lower sales of policies providing a guaranteed return. In this environment, the strategic initiatives launched recently to address our reach and market share in key segments are progressing, albeit slower than originally planned. The level of new group business inflows for the period remained unchanged relative to the first half of 2004. A 6% increase in policy benefit payments and a 12% rise in policy surrenders and terminations lead to a net outflow of R2 billion in respect of life insurance business for the period. Overall, new investment inflows continued the upward trend of the recent past and attracted more than R20 billion in gross new inflows. This was greatly assisted by strong flows to both our local and international multi-managers, and a strong growth in inflows to our Private and Collective Investments businesses. SIM received new third party wholesale mandates of R4,6 billion during the six- month period, somewhat lower than the R5 billion received in the first half of 2004. SFS UK attracted new inflows of R2,5 billion, which is some 7% lower than the first six months of 2004. The Public Investment Commissioner withdrew R6 billion of its funds under management from SIM in March 2005 as part of the restructuring of its investment process and mandates. Notwithstanding this withdrawal, the Group achieved positive net investment inflows of some R1 billion for the six months. Investments under management or administration amounted to R375 billion at the end of June 2005. Embedded value of new business The embedded value of new life business (VNB) for the six months decreased by 14% to R114 million. This is to a large extent the result of sluggish new business volumes, which also impacted on unit costs and the margin of new business, but also an improved allocation of acquisition costs in Employee Benefits. The annual premium equivalent (APE) for the first six months remained virtually unchanged from 2004 at R919 million, whilst the APE margin decreased to 12,4% from the 14,5% recorded in the first half of 2004. In line with the future disclosure proposed for the industry, the profit margin is also expressed as a percentage of the present value of total new business premiums. On this basis the margin reduced from 1,9% to 1,6%. Solvency The capital of Sanlam Life Insurance Limited increased by R1,8 billion from 31 December 2004 (after paying a dividend of R1,3 billion), to R27,6 billion at the end of the period and CAR (Capital Adequacy Requirements) cover calculated on the regulatory capital amounted to 3,8 at the end of June 2005, compared to 3,6 at the end of December 2004. Embedded value Sanlam group"s embedded value amounted to R39,3 billion at the end of June 2005 - 7% up on the R36,6 billion at the end of December 2004. After taking the dividend of R1,4 billion paid into account, the return on embedded value amounted to 23,2% annualised. The annualised return per share is also 23,2%. The value of the Life insurance cluster"s in-force book amounted to R8,9 billion, after taking into account the cost of capital at risk of R1,6 billion. Annualised growth from life business, based on the starting value of the in-force life business, amounted to 16,6%. Dividend In line with past practice, no interim dividend has been declared. Sanlam declares an annual dividend at year-end. ACCOUNTING POLICIES AND ACTUARIAL BASIS Statement of compliance The accounting policies adopted for the purposes of the financial statements comply with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), specifically IAS 34 on interim financial reporting, and with applicable legislation. The policy liabilities and profit entitlement rules are determined in accordance with prevailing legislation, generally accepted actuarial practice and the stipulations contained in the demutualisation proposal. There have been no material changes in the financial soundness valuation basis since 31 December 2004. Adoption of IFRS Being a first-time adopter of IFRS for the 2005 financial year, the Group"s date of transition to IFRS is 1 January 2004. The Group"s opening balance sheet on 1 January 2004 and comparative information for 2004 have been restated to comply with all IFRS expected to be effective as at 31 December 2005. The migration to IFRS for insurers will, in its full extent, take a number of years. The interim results have been prepared in accordance with current interpretations of IFRS. Future results may be impacted, as the development of guidance for the long-term insurance industry, both from an accounting and actuarial perspective is an ongoing process. The South African standard applicable to long-term insurers, AC121 has been withdrawn concurrently with the introduction of IFRS. Therefore, long-term insurers will no longer have any form of exemption from applying normal consolidation principles in instances where investments are held in policyholder portfolios to fund policyholder benefits. In terms of South African Generally Accepted Accounting Practice (SA GAAP) the shareholders" fund"s investments in associated companies were carried at their original cost plus the shareholders" fund"s share of its retained earnings after acquisition (effectively carried at net asset value including goodwill, if any). In respect of the investment in Absa, the equity-accounted carrying value was further adjusted to reflect the investment at fair value. Similarly, the investments in Safair Lease Finance and Peermont were also recognised at fair value. These adjustments to fair value are not allowed in the absence of AC121 and Sanlam is required to reflect the shareholders" fund"s investment in these companies at the equity-accounted carrying value. The policyholders" fund"s investment in Absa must also be carried at original cost plus its share of retained earnings after acquisition. Portfolio investments in subsidiary companies (e.g. Santam) can no longer be accounted for at market value but be carried at consolidated net asset value. Portfolio investments in Sanlam shares have to be treated as treasury shares and deducted from equity on consolidation. The result is a mismatch between the valuation of long-term policy liabilities, which continues to include the affected investments on a marked to market basis, and the policyholder assets underlying these liabilities, which may not be at fair value or may be eliminated on consolidation. The movement in mismatch in any particular period, referred to above, is accounted for through an income statement transfer to or from the shareholders" fund, impacting on Headline and Attributable earnings as well as net asset value. An appropriate adjustment is made to the value of the shareholders" fund for Embedded Value and Capital Adequacy Requirement purposes to reverse this impact. Transitional provisions IFRS 1 First-time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards requires retrospective compliance with all IFRS expected to be effective at the end of the first IFRS reporting period. However, it contains a number of exemptions to this full retrospective application of IFRS. The Group has applied the following exemptions: Business combinations The Group has elected not to apply IFRS 3 Business Combinations retrospectively to business combinations that occurred prior to 1 January 2004. Accordingly, no adjustments have been made to the accounting treatment of these business combinations. Property and equipment The Group has elected to use the previous SA GAAP revaluation of selected property and equipment as deemed cost on the date of transition to IFRS. Cumulative translation differences The cumulative translation differences in respect of the Group"s foreign operations have been deemed to be zero on the date of transition to IFRS. Designation of financial instruments The majority of the Group"s financial instruments were designated as `available for sale" in terms of SA GAAP. The Group has elected to redesignate these financial instruments to the `at fair value through profit or loss" category in IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement. Share-based payments The Group has elected not to apply IFRS 2 Share-based Payment to equity instruments granted on or before 7 November 2002 or granted after 7 November 2002 but which had vested prior to 1 January 2005. Comparatives In terms of IFRS 1 an entity need not disclose comparative information that complies with IAS 32 Financial Instruments: Disclosure and Presentation, IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement and IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts in its first set of IFRS annual financial statements. In the interest of comparable disclosure, the Group has not applied this exemption. Compound financial instruments The Group has elected not to separate compound financial instruments into equity and liability components where the liability component is no longer outstanding on the date of transition. Changes in reporting structures and accounting policies The implementation of IFRS concurrently with the withdrawal of the specific South African accounting standard applicable to insurers (AC121) required the following changes to the Group"s basis of presentation and accounting policies: - Investments in associated companies and joint ventures The Group"s investments in Absa Limited, Peermont Limited and the Safair Lease Finance joint venture were recognised at fair value in the consolidated balance sheet in terms of SA GAAP. The measurement basis has been changed from fair value to an equity-accounted valuation as the exemptions in IFRS for continued use of a fair value basis do not apply to these investments. - Treasury shares Sanlam Limited shares held in policyholder portfolios are treated as treasury shares under IFRS and recognised as a deduction from equity on consolidation (carried at fair value in terms of SA GAAP). - Consolidation of policyholders" interest in Santam The policyholders" fund"s interest in Santam Limited is consolidated in the balance sheet under IFRS (carried at fair value in terms of SA GAAP). - Goodwill Goodwill in respect of business combinations with an agreement date before 31 March 2004 was previously recognised at cost and written off on a straight-line basis over the lesser of its estimated useful life and twenty years. Goodwill was also reviewed bi-annually for impairment and written down where necessary. Amortisation of goodwill is no longer permitted under IFRS 3 Business Combinations but is subject to at least an annual impairment review. The full amortisation charge for 2004 has been reversed and all goodwill has been tested for impairment as at 1 January 2004, 30 June 2004 and 31 December 2004. An additional impairment was required on 30 June 2004 and 31 December 2004, mainly in respect of the Group"s international operations. - Classification of policy contracts The Group has reclassified policy contracts between the insurance and investment categories based on the IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts criteria. A contract is classified as insurance where Sanlam accepts significant insurance risk by agreeing with the policyholder to pay benefits if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the policyholder or other beneficiary. Significant insurance risk exists where it is expected that for the duration of the policy or part thereof, policy benefits payable on the occurrence of the insured event will exceed the amount payable on early termination, before allowance for expense deductions at early termination. - Investment policy contracts The valuation basis for investment contracts has been changed from the FSV method to fair value. Negative Rand Reserves that were included in the valuation of investment contracts under FSV have been eliminated. Costs directly attributable to the acquisition of investment contracts are capitalised to a deferred acquisition cost (DAC) asset and amortised to the income statement over the term of the contracts. The DAC asset is tested for impairment bi-annually and written down when it is not expected to be fully recovered from future fee income. - Long-term reinsurance contracts Contracts entered into with reinsurers under which the Group is compensated for losses on one or more contracts issued by the Group and which meet the classification requirements for insurance contracts are classified as long-term reinsurance contracts. The expected claims and benefits to which the Group is entitled under these contracts are recognised as assets. The Group assesses its long-term reinsurance assets for impairment. If there is objective evidence that the reinsurance asset is impaired, the carrying amount is reduced to a recoverable amount, and the impairment loss is recognised in the income statement. Long-term insurance liabilities were previously shown net after reinsurance; under IFRS long-term insurance liabilities are shown gross of reinsurance and the asset is disclosed separately. - Reclassification of policy loans Loans granted to policyholders were disclosed as separate assets under AC121. Loans with a legal right of set-off and where the intention is to settle the policy loan and policy liability on a net basis, must be offset in terms of IFRS. The affected loans have been reclassified from investment assets and set off against long-term policy liabilities. - Reclassification of financial instruments The Group has reclassified its financial instruments formerly designated as `available for sale" to the `at fair value through profit or loss" category. All fair value gains and losses (investment surpluses) on these instruments are recognised in the income statement under IFRS. - Reclassification of cell owners" interest Santam"s interests in cell insurance companies are consolidated under IFRS, resulting in a reclassification of the cell owners" interest from minority shareholders" interest to a cell owners" liability. - Consolidation of investment vehicles IFRS requires the consolidation of certain investment vehicles controlled by the Group, e.g. collective investment schemes, which were previously recognised at fair value in the Group balance sheet. A financial liability is recognised for the fair value of external investors" interest where the issued units of the fund are classified as financial liabilities in terms of IFRS. In all other instances, the interest of external investors are recognised as minority shareholders" interest. - Share-based payments Sanlam operates a staff share incentive scheme in terms of which shares are offered to staff on a combined option and deferred delivery basis. With the exception of administration costs incurred in respect of the scheme, no cost was recognised in the income statement under SA GAAP. In terms of IFRS 2 Share- based Payment the scheme is treated as equity-settled transactions and the fair value of share-based payment instruments granted are recognised as an expense in the income statement on a straight-line basis over the vesting period (adjusted to reflect actual levels of vesting), with a corresponding credit to equity. The equity-instruments granted to Ubuntu-Botho as part of the Group"s black economic empowerment transaction have vested before 1 January 2005 and are excluded from the scope of IFRS 2. - Elimination of inter-company transactions Inter-company transactions at arm"s length, which do not influence the Group"s net earnings, were previously not eliminated from the results to fairly present the activities of the various businesses. In the absence of AC121 inter-company transactions are eliminated in the Group income statement and balance sheet. - Operating leases The South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) recently issued Circular 7/2005, which requires that rental income from operating leases that contain fixed escalation clauses be recognised on a straight-line basis over the lease term. It also requires that the cumulative difference between rental income on a straight-line and accrual basis be recognised on the balance sheet, but does not provide any further guidance on the required accounting treatment in a fair value environment. The income statement adjustment does not represent a valid claim for rental income due from the counter-party to the operating lease. The resultant balance sheet adjustment is accordingly recognised as part of the carrying amount of investment properties, which are subsequently remeasured to fair value in terms of Sanlam"s accounting policies. The adjustment to rental income pursuant to the application of Circular 7/2005 is therefore netted off against investment surpluses. Further analysis and interpretations on the application of Circular 7/2005 are expected in the near term. These will be evaluated to determine any required adjustment to Sanlam"s application of Circular 7/2005, as outlined above, in finalising the full year results. The financial impact of the changes in accounting policies is disclosed in the IFRS Reconciliation of Equity and Earnings. SPECIAL PURPOSE AUDIT REPORT The 30 June 2005 results and the 30 June 2004 comparative information has not been subject to an audit or review by the external auditors. The 31 December 2004 preliminary IFRS financial information has been audited. A copy of the unqualified Special Purpose Audit Report of the joint auditors, Ernst & Young and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc, on the Group"s preliminary IFRS financial information for the year ended 31 December 2004, is available for inspection at the registered office of the company. The report includes emphasis of matters that notes that only a complete set of financial statements can provide a fair presentation of the Group"s financial position, results of operations and cash flows in accordance with IFRS and that they have not audited or reviewed the 30 June 2005 and 30 June 2004 financial information and express no opinion thereon. They further note that the development of additional guidance and interpretations may require amendment of the preliminary IFRS financial information before inclusion as comparative information in the financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2005. GROUP BALANCE SHEET at 30 June 2005 June unaudited December 2005 2004 2004 R R R million
million million ASSETS Property and equipment 217 203 184 Owner-occupied properties 381 386 380 Goodwill 2 191 2 238 2 186 Deferred acquisition costs 1 050 895 994 Long-term reinsurance assets 333 295 318 Investments 200 554 164 555 187 437 Investment properties 14 659 12 086 14 413 Associated companies 6 288 4 611 5 098 Joint ventures 116 76 69 Equities 97 536 75 979 88 084 Public sector stocks and loans 42 064 33 689 44 434 Debentures, insurance policies, preference 17 901 15 431 17 141 shares and other loans Cash, deposits and similar securities 21 990 22 683 18 198 Deferred tax 441 389 440 Short-term insurance technical assets 1 864 1 939 1 980 Working capital assets 34 808 28 473 31 192 Trade and other receivables 25 479 18 271 20 043 Cash, deposits and similar securities 9 329 10 202 11 149 Total assets 241 839 199 373 225 111 Equity and liabilities Shareholders" fund 21 205 18 467 19 685 Minority shareholders" interest 3 305 2 283 3 515 Total equity 24 510 20 750 23 200 Long-term policy liabilities 172 051 146 256 163 556 Insurance contracts 96 948 81 663 92 961 Investment contracts 75 103 64 593 70 595 Term finance 4 901 4 508 6 103 External investors in consolidated funds 4 169 2 200 3 209 Cell owners" interest 86 - 47 Deferred tax 1 279 321 809 Short-term insurance technical provisions 5 632 4 963 5 198 Working capital liabilities 29 211 20 375 22 989 Trade and other payables 28 076 18 942 21 337 Provisions 319 344 465 Taxation 816 1 089 1 187 Total equity and liabilities 241 839 199 373 225 111 GROUP INCOME STATEMENT for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Six months Full unaudited year 2005 2004 2004 Note R R R
million million million Net income 21 783 9 789 41 975 Financial services income 9 161 8 360 17 836 Reinsurance premiums paid (979) (985) (2 303) Reinsurance commission received 193 252 504 Investment income 4 878 4 639 9 658 Investment surpluses 8 759 (2 467) 16 659 Change in fair value of external (229) (10) (379) investors liability Net insurance and investment (15 037) (4 214) (30 081) contract benefits and claims Long-term insurance and investment (12 439) (2 282) (25 814) contract benefits Short-term insurance claims (2 980) (2 251) (5 014) Reinsurance claims received 382 319 747 Expenses (3 464) (3 343) (7 026) Sales remuneration (1 199) (1 082) (2 302) Administration costs (2 265) (2 261) (4 724) Impairment of investments and 6 (36) (263) goodwill Net operating result 3 288 2 196 4 605 Equity-accounted earnings 781 513 1 085 Finance cost (62) - (49) Loss from discontinued operations - (87) (92) Profit before tax 4 007 2 622 5 549 Tax expense 4 (836) (952) (1 771) Shareholders" fund (393) (394) (1 013) Policyholders" fund (443) (558) (758) Profit for the year 3 171 1 670 3 778 Attributable to: Shareholders" fund 2 675 1 343 2 758 Minority shareholders" interest 496 327 1 020 3 171 1 670 3 778 Earnings attributable to shareholders of the company (cents): Continuing operations: Basic earnings per share 7 104,3 57,9 112,3 Diluted earnings per share 7 102,3 57,4 110,9 GROUP STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Six months Full unaudited year 2005 2004 2004 R R R million million million
Shareholders" fund: Balance at beginning of period 19 685 17 622 17 622 Total recognised income 2 865 1 199 2 559 Profit for the year 2 675 1 343 2 758 Equity-accounted earnings 23 (74) (42) Movement in foreign currency 167 (70) (157) translation reserve Cost of treasury shares donated to the - (314) (314) Ubuntu-Botho Community Development Trust Net realised investment surpluses on (57) (56) (126) other treasury shares Share option costs 38 21 51 Dividends paid (1 295) (1 022) (1 022) New shares issued (1) - 865 865 Costs relating to share issuance - (19) (19) Cost of treasury shares acquired (2) (31) 171 69 Balance at end of period 21 205 18 467 19 685 Minority shareholders" interest: Balance at beginning of period 3 515 1 944 1 944 Total recognised income 526 296 1 005 Profit for the year 496 327 1 020 Equity-accounted earnings - (1) - Movement in foreign currency 30 (30) (15) translation reserve Share option costs 2 2 4 Dividends paid (702) (89) (168) Acquisitions, disposals and other (36) 130 730 movements in minority interests Balance at end of period 3 305 2 283 3 515 Shareholders" fund 19 685 17 622 17 622 Minority shareholders" interest 3 515 1 944 1 944 Total equity at beginning of period 23 200 19 566 19 566 Shareholders" fund 21 205 18 467 19 685 Minority shareholders" interest 3 305 2 283 3 515 Total equity at end of period 24 510 20 750 23 200 (1) Comprises 113 million new ordinary shares at R7,65 per share, 56,5 million `A" deferred shares at R0,01 per share and 52 million `A" preference shares at R0,01 per share. (2) Comprises movement in cost of shares held by subsidiaries and the share incentive trust. CASH FLOW STATEMENT for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Six months Full unaudited year
2005 2004 2004 R R R million million million Net cash inflow/(outflow) from operating 2 353 (226) 2 109 activities Discontinued operations - (100) (105) Other 2 353 (126) 2 214 Net cash outflow from investment (580) (1 447) (2 148) activities Net cash (outflow)/inflow from financing (3 429) 67 (777) activities Net decrease in cash and cash equivalents (1 656) (1 606) (816) Cash, deposits and similar securities at 10 953 11 769 11 769 beginning of period Cash, deposits and similar securities at 9 297 10 163 10 953 end of period IFRS RECONCILIATION OF EQUITY AND EARNINGS Six Full year months unaudited
June 2004 2004 R million R million Reconciliation of reported earnings: Attributable earnings reported under SA GAAP 1 463 3 283 Withdrawal of AC121: Difference between fair value-based earnings and equity-accounted earnings for the shareholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (549) (2 942) Peermont (1) 17 (246) Safair Lease Finance (1) 70 67 Change in value shortfall of the policyholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (133) (384) Santam (2) 93 46 Vukile (2) - (71) Satrix (2) (8) (113) Sanlam (3) 18 (632) Elimination of dividend paid to (60) (60) policyholders (3) Adoption of IFRS: New business strain from investment (6) (13) contracts (4) Share option costs (5) (21) (51) Goodwill amortisation (6) 179 328 Goodwill impairment (6) (36) (42) Reclassification of available for sale 316 3 588 investments (7) Profit attributable to shareholders" fund 1 343 2 758 under IFRS IFRS RECONCILIATION OF EQUITY AND EARNINGS (continued) 31 December 2004
Assets Liabil- Minority Share- ities share- holders" holders" fund interest
R million R million R million R million Reconciliation of equity: Reported under SA GAAP 228 024 197 586 2 796 27 642 Withdrawal of AC121: Reduction in carrying value of shareholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (5 456) (783) (23) (4 650) Peermont (1) (386) (67) - (319) Safair Lease Finance (1) (225) - - (225) Reduction in carrying value of policyholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (613) (34) - (579) Santam (2) (90) - - (90) Vukile (2) 2 140 1 483 728 (71) Satrix (2) 483 739 - (256) Sanlam (3) (1 824) - - (1 824) Consolidation of investment 2 539 2 507 32 - vehicles (8) Elimination of inter-company (897) (897) - - transactions (9) Reclassification of policy (258) (258) - - loans (10) Adoption of IFRS: Change in carrying value of - 1 270 (2) (1 268) investment contracts (4) Recognition of deferred 994 - - 994 acquisition costs asset (4) Tax effect of change in 80 - - 80 investment contract valuation basis (4) Goodwill amortisation (6) 358 - 30 328 Goodwill impairment (6) (48) - (6) (42) Reclassification of long-term 318 318 - - reinsurance assets (11) Revaluation of trading account (42) - - (42) assets and liabilities (12) Change in carrying value of 14 - 7 7 other associated companies (13) Reclassification of cell - 47 (47) - owners" interest (14) Reported under IFRS 225 111 201 911 3 515 19 685 IFRS RECONCILIATION OF EQUITY AND EARNINGS (continued) 30 June 2004 - unaudited Assets Liabil- Minority Share- ities share- holders"
holders" fund interest R million R million R million R million Reconciliation of equity: Reported under SA GAAP 202 270 177 092 2 248 22 930 Withdrawal of AC121: Reduction in carrying value of shareholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (2 616) (310) (16) (2 290) Peermont (1) (74) (18) - (56) Safair Lease Finance (1) (222) - - (222) Reduction in carrying value of policyholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (352) (24) - (328) Santam (2) (43) - - (43) Vukile (2) - - - - Satrix (2) 566 717 - (151) Sanlam (3) (1 293) - - (1 293) Consolidation of investment 1 529 1 510 19 - vehicles (8) Elimination of inter-company (1 561) (1 561) - - transactions (9) Reclassification of policy (238) (238) - - loans (10) Adoption of IFRS: Change in carrying value of - 1 160 - (1 160) investment contracts (4) Recognition of deferred 895 - - 895 acquisition costs asset (4) Tax effect of change in 77 - - 77 investment contract valuation basis (4) Goodwill amortisation (6) 204 - 25 179 Goodwill impairment (6) (36) - - (36) Reclassification of long-term 295 295 - - reinsurance assets (11) Revaluation of trading account (42) - - (42) assets and liabilities (12) Change in carrying value of 14 - 7 7 other associated companies (13) Reclassification of cell - - - - owners" interest (14) Reported under IFRS 199 373 178 623 2 283 18 467 IFRS RECONCILIATION OF EQUITY AND EARNINGS (continued) 1 January 2004 - unaudited
Assets Liabil- Minority Share- ities share- holders" holders" fund interest
R million R million R million R million Reconciliation of equity: Reported under SA GAAP 196 056 172 438 1 931 21 687 Withdrawal of AC121: Reduction in carrying value of shareholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (1 822) (148) (8) (1 666) Peermont (1) (91) (18) - (73) Safair Lease Finance (1) (292) - - (292) Reduction in carrying value of policyholders" fund"s investment in: Absa (1) (206) (11) - (195) Santam (2) (136) - - (136) Vukile (2) - - - - Satrix (2) 547 690 - (143) Sanlam (3) (1 344) - - (1 344) Consolidation of investment 1 418 1 404 14 - vehicles (8) Elimination of inter-company (375) (375) - - transactions (9) Reclassification of policy (207) (207) - - loans (10) Adoption of IFRS: Change in carrying value of - 1 092 - (1 092) investment contracts (4) Recognition of deferred 836 - - 836 acquisition costs asset (4) Tax effect of change in 75 - - 75 investment contract valuation basis (4) Goodwill amortisation (6) - - - - Goodwill impairment (6) - - - - Reclassification of long-term 232 232 - - reinsurance assets (11) Revaluation of trading account (42) - - (42) assets and liabilities (12) Change in carrying value of 14 - 7 7 other associated companies (13) Reclassification of cell - - - - owners" interest (14) Reported under IFRS 194 663 175 097 1 944 17 622 Notes on IFRS implementation adjustments: Investments in associated companies and joint venture The Group"s investments in Absa Limited, Peermont Limited and the Safair Lease Finance joint venture were recognised at fair value in terms of SA GAAP. IFRS does not allow the continued use of a fair value basis for these investments, resulting in a reduction in the carrying value from fair value to an equity- accounted valuation. Reported earnings are adjusted with the difference between the fair value-based investment return and equity-accounted earnings. Policyholders" fund"s investment in subsidiaries In terms of SA GAAP the policyholders" fund"s investments in Santam and Vukile, subsidiaries of the Sanlam group, and Satrix, now a consolidated fund, were accounted for as equity investments at fair value. In terms of IFRS the policyholders" interest must be consolidated and measured at net asset value. Reported earnings are adjusted with the difference between the fair value-based investment return and the consolidated earnings. Policyholders" fund"s investment in Sanlam shares In terms of SA GAAP the policyholders" fund"s investment in Sanlam Limited shares was accounted for as an equity investment at fair value. In terms of IFRS the policyholders" interest must be treated as treasury shares and recognised as a deduction from equity on consolidation. Reported earnings are adjusted with the investment return earned on the Sanlam shares held by policyholder portfolios. Measurement of investment policy contracts Investment contracts issued by Sanlam Life Insurance Limited were measured under SA GAAP using bases similar to the Financial Soundness Valuation (FSV) method. These contracts are valued at fair value in terms of IFRS, requiring an adjustment to their carrying value. The FSV valuation includes specific allowance for commission and other issuing costs. In a fair value environment, the FSV cost allowance is replaced by a deferred acquisition costs (DAC) asset in terms of IAS 18 Revenue. The new business strain, as well as the increase in the total net liability recognised in respect of investment contracts, result primarily from the difference between the incremental cost that can be capitalised to DAC in terms of IFRS and the level of cost allowance inherent to the FSV method. Share option costs IFRS 2 Share-based Payment requires the recognition of an income statement expense in respect of equity instruments granted to participants of the Group"s share incentive schemes. No income statement effect was recognised in terms of SA GAAP, except for administration costs incurred in respect of the schemes. Goodwill amortisation and impairment Goodwill in respect of business combinations with an agreement date prior to 31 March 2004 was amortised under SA GAAP and subject to an impairment review. Goodwill is not amortised under IFRS but subject to at least an annual impairment review. Goodwill amortised under SA GAAP during the 2004 financial year has been reversed in terms of IFRS 1. All goodwill has been tested for impairment as at 1 January 2004, 30 June 2004 and 31 December 2004. An additional impairment was required on 30 June 2004 and 31 December 2004, mainly in respect of the Group"s international operations. Reclassification of available for sale investments In terms of SA GAAP (AC133) the Group classified the majority of its investments as `available for sale" and elected to transfer unrealised investment surpluses directly to equity. In terms of IFRS 1 the Group has reclassified these financial instruments as `at fair value through profit or loss" (refer `Transitional provisions" section). Unrealised investment surpluses formerly reported directly in equity have been transferred to the income statement. Consolidation of investment vehicles IFRS requires the consolidation of certain investment vehicles controlled by the Group, e.g. collective investment schemes, which were previously recognised at fair value in the Group balance sheet. Elimination of inter-company transactions Inter-company transactions at arm"s length, which do not influence the Group"s net earnings, were previously not eliminated from the results to fairly present the activities of the various businesses. In the absence of AC121 inter-company transactions are eliminated with no net impact on the shareholders" fund. Reclassification of policy loans Loans granted to policyholders were disclosed as separate assets under AC121. Loans with a legal right of set-off and where the intention is to settle the policy loan and policy liability on a net basis, must be offset in terms of IFRS. The affected loans have been reclassified from investment assets to long- term policy liabilities. Reclassification of long-term reinsurance assets Contracts entered into with reinsurers under which the Group is compensated for losses on one or more contracts issued by the Group and that meet the classification requirements for insurance contracts were previously offset against long-term insurance contract liabilities. These reinsurance assets have been reclassified from long-term policy liabilities to a separate asset class in terms of the disclosure requirements of IFRS 4. Revaluation of trading account assets and liabilities The valuation of certain unquoted trading assets and liabilities was adjusted to comply with the requirements of the revised IAS 39, among others in respect of the treatment of day one profits. Change in carrying value of other associated companies The post acquisition equity-accounted earnings of certain associated companies have been changed as a result of the transition to IFRS. Reclassification of cell owners" interest Santam"s interests in cell insurance companies are consolidated under IFRS, resulting in a reclassification of the cell owners" interest from minority shareholders" interest to a cell owners" liability. ABRIDGED SHAREHOLDERS" FUND BALANCE SHEET - NET ASSET VALUE (All businesses consolidated at NAV) at 30 June 2005 June unaudited December 2005 2004 2004 R million R million R million Assets Goodwill 2 175 2 238 2 170 Investments 28 440 23 747 26 582 Working capital and other assets 30 763 25 088 26 748 Total assets 61 378 51 073 55 500 Equity and liabilities Shareholders" fund 21 205 18 467 19 685 Minority shareholders" interest 2 583 2 423 2 932 Term finance, working capital and 37 590 30 183 32 883 other liabilities Total equity and liabilities 61 378 51 073 55 500 ABRIDGED SHAREHOLDERS" FUND BALANCE SHEET - FAIR VALUE (Group businesses, associates and joint venture below reflected as investments at fair value) at 30 June 2005 June unaudited December 2005 2004 2004 R million R million R million
Assets Property and equipment 144 103 106 Owner-occupied properties 369 369 370 Goodwill (1) 389 372 387 Deferred acquisition costs 122 - - Investments 37 404 28 106 34 794 Sanlam businesses 7 910 5 622 7 743 Investment Management (2) 2 572 2 079 2 384 Sanlam Financial Services 379 356 349 Sanlam Capital Markets 444 399 441 Innofin 232 145 187 Santam 3 851 2 613 4 028 Other (3) 432 30 354 Associated companies 11 405 6 529 10 033 Absa 10 250 6 254 9 429 African Life Assurance 521 - - Peermont 634 275 604 Joint venture - Safair Lease 278 298 270 Finance Other investments 17 811 15 657 16 748 Other equities 7 840 6 262 6 739 Public sector stocks and loans 1 494 2 388 1 550 Investment properties 571 505 619 Other interest-bearing and 7 906 6 502 7 840 preference share investments Deferred tax 310 227 313 Working capital assets 5 669 6 148 6 657 Total assets 44 407 35 325 42 627 Equity and liabilities Shareholders" fund 32 101 23 747 29 782 Minority shareholders" interest 53 - 61 Term finance 3 791 4 819 5 064 External investors in 98 74 51 consolidated funds Deferred tax 1 105 391 1 143 Working capital liabilities 7 259 6 294 6 526 Total equity and liabilities 44 407 35 325 42 627 Net asset value per share 1 178 868 1 093 (cents) The goodwill relates mainly to the consolidation of Merchant Investors Assurance and is excluded in the build-up of the Group embedded value, as the current value of in-force business for this life insurance company is included in the embedded value. Included in Investment Management are Sanlam Investment Management, Sanlam Collective Investments and the Investment Cluster"s international businesses. Other businesses comprise the non-life businesses in the Life Insurance cluster, which are excluded from the value of in-force and all the businesses in the Independent Financial Services cluster apart from Sanlam Financial Services. ABRIDGED SHAREHOLDERS" FUND BALANCE SHEET - FAIR VALUE (continued) Assets Minority Share- share- holders"
holders" fund interest R R million R million million
Reconciliation of equity - fair value: 31 December 2004 Reported under SA GAAP 30 045 63 29 982 Change in carrying value of (196) (2) (194) investment contracts Revaluation of trading account (42) - (42) assets and liabilities Goodwill amortisation reversed - 36 - 36 Merchant Investors Assurance Reported under IFRS 29 843 61 29 782 30 June 2004 - unaudited Reported under SA GAAP 23 958 - 23 958 Change in carrying value of (188) - (188) investment contracts Revaluation of trading account (42) - (42) assets and liabilities Goodwill amortisation reversed - 19 - 19 Merchant Investors Assurance Reported under IFRS 23 747 - 23 747 1 January 2004 - unaudited Reported under SA GAAP 22 819 - 22 819 Change in carrying value of (181) - (181) investment contracts Revaluation of trading account (42) - (42) assets and liabilities Reported under IFRS 22 596 - 22 596 ABRIDGED SHAREHOLDERS" FUND BALANCE SHEET - FAIR VALUE (continued) Six months unaudited Full year 2005 2004 2004 R million R million R million
SANLAM BUSINESSES AND INVESTMENTS: EXCESS OF FAIR VALUE OVER NET ASSET VALUE The shareholders" fund balance sheet at fair value includes the value of the companies below based on directors" valuation, apart from Santam, Absa, African Life Assurance and Peermont, which are valued according to ruling share prices. Net asset value of businesses and 9 223 7 273 8 426 investments Investment Management (1) 486 369 514 Sanlam Financial Services UK 355 391 335 Sanlam Capital Markets 444 399 441 Innofin 157 141 155 Santam 2 398 2 052 2 655 Absa 4 498 3 674 4 030 African Life Assurance 521 - - Peermont 229 201 218 Safair Lease Finance 71 46 45 Other (2) 64 - 33 Goodwill recognised in respect of above 1 198 1 198 1 198 companies Deferred capital gains tax on investments 936 437 1 146 at fair value Revaluation adjustment of interest to fair 8 236 3 541 7 276 value Fair value of businesses and investments 19 593 12 449 18 046 Analysis of fair value Sanlam businesses 7 910 5 622 7 743 Associated companies 11 405 6 529 10 033 Joint venture - Safair Lease Finance 278 298 270 Fair value of businesses and investments 19 593 12 449 18 046 (1) Included in Investment Management are Sanlam Investment Management, Sanlam Collective Investments and the Investment cluster"s international businesses. (2) Other businesses comprise the non-life businesses in the Life Insurance cluster, which are excluded from the value of in-force and all the businesses in the Independent Financial Services cluster apart from Sanlam Financial Services. RECONCILIATION OF EARNINGS to segmental analysis Six months ended 30 June 2005 - unaudited
Shareholder Policy- activities holder Active- ties
R million Total Financia Investme l nt services return Net income 21 783 9 078 1 170 11 535 Financial services income 9 161 9 183 (2) (20) Reinsurance premiums paid (979) (979) - - Reinsurance commission received 193 193 - - Investment income 4 878 657 397 3 824 Investment surpluses 8 759 24 788 7 947 Change in fair value of external (229) - (13) (216) investors liability Net insurance and investment (15 037) (4 046) - (10 contract benefits and claims 991) Long-term insurance and investment (12 (1 448) - (10 contract benefits 439) 991) Short-term insurance claims (2 980) (2 980) - - Reinsurance claims received 382 382 - - Expenses (3 464) (3 459) - (5) Sales remuneration (1 199) (1 199) - - Administration costs (2 265) (2 260) - (5) Impairment of investments and 6 - 6 - goodwill Net operating result 3 288 1 573 1 176 539 Equity-accounted earnings 781 - 713 68 Finance cost (62) - - (62) Loss from discontinued operations - - - - Profit before tax 4 007 1 573 1 889 545 Tax expense (836) (364) (29) (443) Shareholders" fund (393) (364) (29) - Policyholders" fund (443) - - (443) Profit for the year 3 171 1 209 1 860 102 Attributable to: Shareholders" fund 2 675 1 006 1 669 - Minority shareholders" interest 496 203 191 102 3 171 1 209 1 860 102 RECONCILIATION OF EARNINGS to segmental analysis Six months ended 30 June 2004 - unaudited Shareholder Policy- activities holder
Active- ties R million Total Financia Investme l nt
services return Net income 9 789 8 203 145 1 441 Financial services income 8 360 8 380 (3) (17) Reinsurance premiums paid (985) (985) - - Reinsurance commission received 252 252 - - Investment income 4 639 556 368 3 715 Investment surpluses (2 467) - (204) (2 263) Change in fair value of external (10) - (16) 6 investors liability Net insurance and investment (4 214) (3 291) - (923) contract benefits and claims Long-term insurance and investment (2 282) (1 359) - (923) contract benefits Short-term insurance claims (2 251) (2 251) - - Reinsurance claims received 319 319 - - Expenses (3 343) (3 339) - (4) Sales remuneration (1 082) (1 082) - - Administration costs (2 261) (2 257) - (4) Impairment of investments and (36) - (36) - goodwill Net operating result 2 196 1 573 109 514 Equity-accounted earnings 513 - 464 49 Finance cost - - - - Loss from discontinued operations (87) (94) 7 - Profit before tax 2 622 1 479 580 563 Tax expense (952) (381) (13) (558) Shareholders" fund (394) (381) (13) - Policyholders" fund (558) - - (558) Profit for the year 1 670 1 098 567 5 Attributable to: Shareholders" fund 1 343 848 495 - Minority shareholders" interest 327 250 72 5 1 670 1 098 567 5 RECONCILIATION OF EARNINGS to segmental analysis Year ended 31 December 2004 Shareholder Policy-
activities holder Active- ties R million Total Financia Investme l nt services return Net income 41 975 17 170 879 23 926 Financial services income 17 836 17 886 (7) (43) Reinsurance premiums paid (2 303) (2 303) - - Reinsurance commission 504 504 - - received Investment income 9 658 1 083 789 7 786 Investment surpluses 16 659 - 127 16 532 467) 263) Change in fair value of (379) - (30) (349) external investors liability Net insurance and (30 081) (6 965) - (23 investment contract 116) benefits and claims Long-term insurance and (25 (2 698) - (23 investment contract 814) 116) benefits Short-term insurance (5 014) (5 014) - - claims Reinsurance claims 747 747 - - received Expenses (7 026) (6 996) (1) (29) Sales remuneration (2 302) (2 302) - - Administration costs (4 724) (4 694) (1) (29) Impairment of investments (263) - (263) - and goodwill Net operating result 4 605 3 209 615 781 Equity-accounted earnings 1 085 - 984 101 Finance cost (49) - - (49) Loss from discontinued (92) (94) 2 - operations Profit before tax 5 549 3 115 1 601 833 Tax expense (1 771) (789) (224) (758) Shareholders" fund (1 013) (789) (224) - Policyholders" fund (758) - - (758) Profit for the year 3 778 2 326 1 377 75 Attributable to: Shareholders" fund 2 758 1 812 946 - Minority shareholders" 1 020 514 431 75 interest 3 778 2 326 1 377 75 NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Six months unaudited Full yea 2005 2004 2004 R million R million R milli FUNDS RECEIVED FROM CLIENTS Life insurance 5 207 5 367 11 200 Investments 20 788 18 192 40 933 Short-term insurance 4 139 3 584 7 719 Total new business 30 134 27 143 59 852 Premiums on existing business 5 354 5 269 10 879 Total funds received from clients 35 488 32 412 70 731 Funds received from short-term insurance are recognised in the income statement. All other funds received are recognised directly in the balance sheet or as segregated funds as applicable; fee income earned on this business is recognised in the income statement. payments TO CLIENTS Life insurance 12 599 12 383 25 517 Risk underwriting benefits 1 382 1 294 2 568 Other payments 11 217 11 089 22 949 Investments 19 730 9 704 24 226 Short-term insurance 2 664 2 062 4 397 Total payments to clients 34 993 24 149 54 140 Life insurance risk underwriting benefits and short-term insurance payments are recognised in the income statement; all other payments to clients are recognised directly in the balance sheet or as segregated fund flows as applicable. NET FLOW OF FUNDS Life insurance (2 038) (1 747) (3 438) Investments 1 058 8 488 16 707 Short-term insurance 1 475 1 522 3 322 Total net inflow of funds 495 8 263 16 591 TAXATION Result from financial services 364 381 789 Current year 364 381 793 Prior year - - (4) Investment income - current year 62 47 92 Investment surpluses (120) (34) 232 Secondary Tax on Companies 87 - (100) Tax expense - shareholders" fund 393 394 1 013 Tax expense - policyholders" fund 443 558 758 Total income tax charged to income statement 836 952 1 771 SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS - SHAREHOLDERS" FUND Financial services Life insurance 777 704 1 493 Short-term insurance 532 663 1 361 Investment management 269 208 419 Sanlam Capital Markets 51 49 86 Independent Financial Services 26 30 44 Corporate expenses (82) (81) (194) Result from continued operations 1 573 1 573 3 209 Discontinued operations - (94) (94) Result from financial services before tax 1 573 1 479 3 115 Investment return Life insurance 2 546 1 290 7 287 Short-term insurance 410 161 1 062 Investment management (5) (5) 48 Sanlam Capital Markets - 23 - Independent Financial Services - (31) (52) Corporate and other 718 527 1 022 Consolidation (1 780) (1 392) (7 768) Result from continued operations 1 889 573 1 599 Discontinued operations - 7 2 Investment return before tax 1 889 580 1 601 Investment INCOME - SHAREHOLDERS" FUND Interest-bearing investments 234 175 445 Equities 120 174 312 Properties 43 19 32 Investment income before consolidation 397 368 789 Dividends from associated companies 273 139 264 Total investment income 670 507 1 053 EARNINGS PER SHARE Basic earnings per share: Net result from financial services 39,2 34,3 71,4 Core earnings 60,7 50,7 104,8 Headline earnings 104,5 56,0 116,8 Adjusted headline earnings based on the long-87,7 76,2 160,4 term rate of return Profit from continuing operations 104,3 57,9 112,3 attributable to shareholders" fund Loss from discontinued operations - (3,5) (3,6) attributable to shareholders" fund Diluted earnings per share: Net result from financial services 38,5 34,0 70,5 Core earnings 59,4 50,2 103,4 Headline earnings 102,5 55,5 115,3 Adjusted headline earnings based on the long-86,0 75,5 158,3 term rate of return Profit from continuing operations 102,3 57,4 110,9 attributable to shareholders" fund Loss from discontinued operations - (3,5) (3,6) attributable to shareholders" fund Analysis of earnings: Net result from financial services 1 006 848 1 812 Net investment income 550 403 847 Investment income per note 6 670 507 1 053 Tax on investment income (62) (47) (92) Minority shareholders" interest (58) (57) (114) Core earnings 1 556 1 251 2 659 Net equity-accounted headline earnings 421 341 718 Equity-accounted headline earnings 443 341 747 (excluding dividends received) Minority shareholders" interest (22) - (29) Net investment surpluses 791 (208) (514) Investment surpluses 782 (227) 32 Tax on investment surpluses 120 34 (232) Minority shareholders" interest (111) (15) (314) Secondary tax on companies (87) - 100 Headline earnings 2 681 1 384 2 963 Non-headline earnings (6) (41) (205) Profit for the period 2 675 1 343 2 758 Adjusted headline earnings based on the long-2 250 1 882 4 070 term rate of return Profit from continuing operations 2 675 1 430 2 850 attributable to shareholders" fund Loss from discontinued operations - (87) (92) attributable to shareholders" fund Number of shares: Number of ordinary shares in issue at 2 767,6 2 654,6 2 654,6 beginning of period Add: Weighted number of shares issued - 28,3 84,8 Less: Weighted Sanlam shares held by (202,9) (213,5) (201,6) subsidiaries (including policyholders) Adjusted weighted average number of shares 2 564,7 2 469,4 for basic earnings per share 2 537,8 Add: Conversion of deferred shares 6,9 3,0 3,0 Add: Total number of shares under option 119,9 128,9 132,1 Less: Number of shares (under option) that (75,7) (108,7) would have been issued at fair value (102,1) Adjusted weighted average number of shares 2 615,8 2 492,6 for diluted earnings per share 2 570,8 Number of ordinary shares in issue 2 767,6 2 767,6 2 767,6 Shares held by subsidiaries in shareholders" (49,9) (30,4) (47,5) fund Convertible deferred shares held by Ubuntu- 7,7 - 5,8 Botho Adjusted number of shares for value per 2 725,4 2 737,2 2 725,9 share 8. ASSETS UNDER MANAGEMENT AND ADMINISTRATION (r million) Total assets per Group balance sheet 241 839 199 373 225 111 Segregated funds not included in Group 133 104 92 362 121 678 balance sheet Total assets under management and 374 943 291 735 346 789 administration 9. CONTINGENT LIABILITIES The Pension Fund Adjudicator recently issued a number of rulings that could have potentially significant implications for Sanlam and the insurance industry as a whole. Refer to the executive review for further information. Shareholders are also referred to the contingent liabilities disclosed in the 2004 annual report. The circumstances surrounding these contingent liabilities remained unchanged Adjusted headline earnings - LTRR Six months unaudited Full year 2005 2004 2004
R million R million R million The LTRR investment return is determined by applying the long-term expected return of 10% (2004: 11%) to the average monthly shareholders" fund investments Adjusted headline earnings - long-term rate of return (LTRR) Net result from financial services 1 006 848 1 812 Secondary tax on companies (87) - 100 LTRR investment return after taxation 1 331 1 034 2 158 Equity-accounted headline earnings 421 341 718 LTRR investment return - balanced 910 693 1 440 portfolio Adjusted earnings - LTRR 2 250 1 882 4 070 Reconciliation of headline earnings and LTRR headline earnings Headline earnings per note 7 2 681 1 384 2 963 Fund Transfers (91) 90 1 214 Net LTRR adjustment (340) 408 (107) Adjusted headline earnings - LTRR 2 250 1 882 4 070 Analysis of net LTRR adjustment Investment return (185) 584 (300) Equities (278) 388 (331) Interest-bearing investments 133 194 47 Properties (40) 2 (16) Tax (216) (149) (65) Minority shareholders" interest 61 (27) 258 Net LTRR adjustment (340) 408 (107) AssetS subject to LTRR Investments per shareholders" fund balance 28 440 23 747 26 582 sheet at net asset value Less: Investment in associated companies (5 604) (4 035) (4 544) Investment in joint ventures (116) (76) (69) Investments held in respect of term (3 718) (3 417) (3 809) finance Investments held in respect of capital (109) (89) (62) market activity Investments from discontinued operations, (781) (797) (905) matched by liabilities Other (413) (338) (104) LTRR investments 17 699 14 995 17 089 Embedded Value for the six months ended 30 June 2005 Six months unaudited Full year 2005 2004 2004
R million R million R million Embedded Value Sanlam group shareholders" fund at fair 32 101 23 747 29 782 value Adjustment for discounting capital gains 176 111 138 tax (1) Adjustment to include business under value (356) (372) (356) of in-force (2) Present value of strategic corporate (772) (641) (883) expenses (3) Fair value of share incentive scheme (4) (668) (375) (799) STC deferred tax asset written down (5) (100) - (100) Sanlam group shareholders adjusted net 30 381 22 470 27 782 assets Net value of life insurance business in- 8 882 8 011 8 851 force (2) Value of life insurance business in-force 10 497 9 418 10 285 - Individual business 9 447 8 090 9 147 - Employee benefits 1 050 1 328 1 138 Cost of capital at risk (1 563) (1 407) (1 400) - Individual business (1 237) (986) (1 128) - Employee benefits (326) (421) (272) Minority shareholders" interest in value (52) - (34) of in-force Sanlam group embedded value 39 263 30 481 36 633 Embedded value per share (cents) (6) 1 441 1 114 1 344 Number of shares (million) (6) 2 725 2 737 2 726 2. embedded value EARNINGS Embedded value from new life insurance 114 133 321 business (7) Earnings from existing life insurance 798 741 1 363 business Expected return 591 587 1 148 Operating experience variations (8) 137 113 144 Operating assumption changes 70 41 71 Embedded value earnings from life 912 874 1 684 operations Economic assumption changes (9) (319) (48) 197 Tax changes (10) (87) - - Investment variances 184 (183) 253 Exchange rate movements 36 (21) (37) Change in minority shareholders" interest (18) - (34) in value of in-force Growth from life insurance business 708 622 2 063 Investment return on shareholders adjusted 3 185 1 031 6 389 net assets Change in fair value of share incentive 131 56 (368) scheme Total embedded value earnings before dividends are paid, capital raised and 4 024 1 709 8 084 cost of treasury shares acquired Dividends paid (1 363) (1 082) (1 082) Capital raised - 848 846 Cost of treasury shares acquired (31) (176) (397) Change in Sanlam group embedded value 2 630 1 299 7 451 Growth from life insurance business as a % 16,6% 16,1% 26,5% of beginning value of in-force* Return on embedded value* (6) 23,2% 11,5% 27,7% Return on embedded value per share* (6) 23,2% 8,0% 22,6% * annualised returns for 6-month periods 3. NEW BUSINESS Value of new business Gross value of new business 127 144 339 Individual business - RSA 109 119 279 Employee benefits - RSA 10 19 46 International (11) 8 6 14 Cost of capital at risk (13) (11) (18) Individual business - RSA (7) (5) (10) Employee benefits - RSA (4) (4) (5) International (11) (2) (2) (3) Net value of new business (7) 114 133 321 New business profitability ratios (12) Annual Premium Equivalent (APE) (12) 919 917 1 958 Individual business - RSA 704 729 1 489 Employee benefits - RSA 145 141 356 International (11) 70 47 113 Present value of new business premiums 7 175 6 930 15 357 (13) Individual business - RSA 5 200 5 230 11 096 Employee benefits - RSA 1 392 1 345 3 352 International (11) 583 355 909 Net value of new business (7) 114 133 321 Individual business - RSA 102 114 269 Employee benefits - RSA 6 15 41 International (11) 6 4 11 APE margin (12) 12,4% 14,5% 16,4% Individual business - RSA 14,5% 15,6% 18,1% Employee benefits - RSA 4,1% 10,6% 11,5% International (11) 8,6% 8,5% 9,7% Present value of premium margin (12) 1,6% 1,9% 2,1% Individual business - RSA 2,0% 2,2% 2,4% Employee benefits - RSA 0,4% 1,1% 1,2% International (11) 1,0% 1,1% 1,2% Gross value Cost of Net value Change from of in-force capital of in- base business at risk force %
R million R business million R million 4. SENSITIVITY Value of in-force business less cost of capital Base value 10 497 (1 563) 8 934 Increase risk discount rate 9 844 (1 864) 7 980 (11%) by 1,0% to 11,6% Decrease risk discount rate 11 250 (1 207) 10 043 12% by 1,0% to 9,6% Value of new business Base value 127 (13) 114 Increase risk discount rate 107 (16) 91 (20%) by 1,0% to 11,6% Decrease risk discount rate 153 (12) 141 24% by 1,0% to 9,6% METHODOLOGY The embedded value methodology applied is consistent with the methodology used in the 31 December 2004 Embedded Value report. There are no material changes in the methodology used. The embedded value results have been adjusted, where applicable, for the adoption of IFRS for the 2005 interim results. Both the interim and full year 2004 embedded value results have been restated and have not been subject to an audit. PRINCIPAL ASSUMPTIONS June unaudited December 2005 2004 2004 % p.a. % p.a. % p.a. Gross investment return and inflation (14) Fixed-interest securities 8,1 10,4 8,3 Equities and offshore investments 10,1 12,4 10,3 Hedged equities (15) 8,1 9,4 8,3 Property 9,1 11,4 9,3 Cash 6,1 8,4 6,3 Risk discount rate 10,6 12,9 10,8 Return on capital at risk (16) 8,4 11,0 9,1 Unit cost and salary inflation 4,1 6,4 4,3 Consumer price index inflation 3,1 4,9 3,3 Decrements, expenses and bonuses Future mortality, morbidity and discontinuance rates and future expense levels are based on recent experience where appropriate. Future rates of bonuses for traditional participating business, stable bonus business and participating annuities are set at levels that are supportable by the assets backing the respective product asset funds at the respective valuation dates. Sanlam Life"s current surrender and paid-up bases are assumed to be maintained in the future. HIV/Aids Allowance is made, where appropriate, for the impact of expected HIV/Aids- related claims, consistent with the recommendations of the Actuarial Society of South Africa as set out in its proposed Professional Guidance Note 105. Premiums in respect of individual business are assumed to be rerated, where applicable, in line with deterioration in mortality, with a three-year delay from the point where mortality losses would be experienced. Taxation Projected corporate tax is allowed for at a rate of 29% (previously 30%). Allowance is made for capital gains tax. The assumed rollover period for realisation of investments is five years for property and equity assets supporting policy reserves. For property and equity assets supporting capital at risk the assumed rollover period is also five years, except for Santam (ten years) and ABSA (not discounted). Allowance for secondary tax on companies is made by placing a present value on the tax liability generated by the net cash dividends paid that is attributable to the life company. Previously it was assumed that over the long-term the proportion of cash dividends paid would reduce to a level of 50% from the current 100% level. We now assume that all future dividends will be paid in cash. June unaudited December
2005 2004 2004 % % % Long-term asset mix for assets supporting the capital at risk Equities 25 42 42 Hedged equities 35 26 26 Property 5 8 8 Fixed-interest securities 20 20 20 Cash 15 4 4 100 100 100 7. New business premiums Six months Full unaudited year
2005 2004 2004 R R R million million million Financial statements New business premiums 5 207 5 367 11 200 Less: Premium increases (index growth) (300) (289) (619) Plus: Optional reduction in premiums 11 18 36 Less: Other life business (17) (40) (12) (83) Premiums used in the calculation of 4 878 5 084 10 534 annual premium equivalent New business embedded value premiums Recurring premiums 480 454 1 005 Single premiums 4 398 4 630 9 529 Premiums used in the calculation of 4 878 5 084 10 534 annual premium equivalent The embedded value results were adjusted, where applicable, in accordance with IFRS adopted for the 2005 interim results. Both the interim and full year 2004 embedded value results have been restated. Adjustment to allow for the delay before incurring the capital gains tax liability included in the fair value of the shareholders" fund. Reverse goodwill relating to Merchant Investors Assurance (MIA), as its value of in-force business is included in the total value of life insurance business in- force. The June 2005 value is calculated by multiplying half of the projected full year recurring corporate expenses not related to life business (after tax) of R56,5 million by the share price of 1174 cents and dividing by the headline earnings per share based on the long-term rate of return of 86,0 cents. The fair value of the Sanlam employee share incentive scheme has been determined using a statistical model. Actual options outstanding have been valued based on the actual share price and dividend yield at the valuation date. The deferred tax asset in respect of unused STC credits, included in the net asset value, is reversed as the value of in-force business already includes an allowance for the STC expense, after allowing for available STC credits. Total embedded value earnings before dividends paid, capital raised and cost of treasury shares acquired, as a percentage of embedded value at the beginning of the period. Per share values are net of the dilution resulting from the Ubunto- Botho transaction and deferred shares earned for the period. The minority shareholders" interest in the net value of new business for the first half of 2005 amounted to R1 million. The main contributor to the operating experience variation is positive risk experience of R106 million. Economic assumption changes at 30 June 2005 include adjustments to the long-term asset mix assumptions for: Policyholders" funds, leading to a R118 million decrease in the embedded value; and Assets supporting capital at risk, leading to a R200 million decrease in the embedded value. The contributors to this change are: The change in the corporate tax rate from 30% to 29% added R162 million to the embedded value; and The allowance for secondary tax on companies is made by placing a present value on the tax liability generated by net cash dividends paid out by the life company. Previously it was assumed that over the long-term the proportion of cash dividends paid would reduce to a level of 50% from the current 100% level. We now assume that all future dividends will be paid in cash, increasing the allowance for STC by R249 million. International includes Sanlam Namibia and MIA. APE (annual premium equivalent) is equal to new recurring premiums (excluding indexed growth premiums) plus 10% of single premiums. The profitability of new business is measured by both the ratio of value of new business (VNB) to APE, as well as to the present value of new business premiums. Defined as the present value of new recurring premiums plus single premiums for the period. The economic assumptions used for all life business except MIA. The assumed future return for these assets is lower than that of equities, which are not hedged, reflecting the cost of derivative instruments. The investment return on assets supporting the capital at risk is based on the long-term asset mix for these funds. The majority of profits in respect of these premiums accrue to Sanlam Investment Management. Group secretary Registered name: Sanlam Limited Johan Bester (Registration number 1959/001562/06) JSE share code: SLM Registered office NSX share code: SLA 2 Strand Road, Bellville 7530 ISIN number: ZAE000028262 telephone (021) 947-9111 Incorporated in South Africa Fax (021) 947-3670 Transfer secretaries: Computershare Investor Services 2004 Postal address (Proprietary) Limited PO Box 1, Sanlamhof 7532 (Registration number 2004/003647/07) 70 Marshall Street, Johannesburg 2001 PO Box 61051, Marshalltown 2107
Tel 0861 100 913 Fax (011) 688-5201 www.sanlam.co.za Directors: R.C. Andersen (Chairman), P.T. Motsepe (Deputy Chairman), J. van Zyl (Group Chief Executive), M.M.M. Bakane-Tuoane, D.C. Brink, P. de V. Rademeyer, A.S. du Plessis, F.A. du Plessis, W.G. James, V.P. Khanyile, C.E. Maynard, M.V. Moosa, M. Ramos, G.E. Rudman, R.V. Simelane, Z.B. Swanepoel, E. van As, J.J.M. van Zyl. Date: 08/09/2005 08:01:22 AM Supplied by www.sharenet.co.za Produced by the JSE SENS Department

Share This Story