To view the PDF file, sign up for a MySharenet subscription.

STANBIC ANNOUNCEMENT

Release Date: 26/10/1999 11:46
Code(s): SBK SBKP
Wrap Text
STANDARD BANK INVESTMENT CORPORATION LIMITED
(REGISTRATION NUMBER 69/17128/06)
("STANBIC")
STANBIC ANNOUNCEMENT

THE CHAIRMAN OF STANDARD BANK INVESTMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, DR. C.B. STRAUSS YESTERDAY DELIVERED A LETTER TO THE CHAIRMAN OF NEDCOR LIMITED, MR. C.F. LIEBENBERG, THE CONTENTS OF WHICH WERE AS FOLLOWS:
"I REFER TO OUR CORRESPONDENCE AND VARIOUS DISCUSSIONS WHEREBY YOU EXPRESSED A DESIRE TO ADDRESS THE STANBIC BOARD IN SUPPORT OF A PLAN FOR A MERGER WITH NEDCOR BASED ON PREVAILING MARKET VALUES. YOUR VIEWS ON THE MERITS OF YOUR PLAN WERE PRESENTED TO OUR BOARD BY YOUR TEAM ON 5TH OCTOBER.
FOLLOWING YOUR PRESENTATION THE BOARD APPOINTED A SUB-COMMITTEE OF
NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS TO CONSIDER YOUR PLAN IN DETAIL. IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT FULL CONSIDERATION WAS GIVEN TO ALL ASPECTS OF THE PLAN, A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF OUR SENIOR EXECUTIVES AND THEIR SUPPORTING STAFF MEMBERS WERE RELIEVED OF THEIR NORMAL DUTIES TO CONCENTRATE ON THIS MATTER AND WERE ASSISTED BY J.P. MORGAN, DEUTSCHE BANK, MCKINSEY & CO., PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS AND BOWMAN GILFILLAN. THE SUB-COMMITTEE, STANBIC MANAGEMENT AND THE ADVISERS HAVE DEVOTED CONSIDERABLE TIME AND EFFORT IN ASSESSING THE NEDCOR PLAN AS WELL AS CONDUCTING AN INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF THE MERGER AND ITS POTENTIAL BENEFITS. MEMBERS OF THE STANBIC EXECUTIVE HAVE MET WITH NEDCOR EXECUTIVES TO EXPLORE CERTAIN OF THE BUSINESS ASSUMPTIONS UNDERLYING THE NEDCOR PLAN, WHILE J.P. MORGAN AND MCKINSEY & CO. HAVE, INTER ALIA, COMPARED THE NEDCOR PLAN AGAINST INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE AND PRECEDENT.
MANAGEMENT AND ADVISERS HAVE NOW COMPLETED THEIR ANALYSIS AND HAVE REPORTED THEIR FINDINGS TO THE SUB-COMMITTEE AND THE BOARD. THE BOARD MET THIS MORNING AND BASED ON THE RECOMMENDATION OF THE SUB-COMMITTEE AND ADVISERS HAS
UNANIMOUSLY REACHED THE CONCLUSIONS SET OUT IN THIS LETTER.
OUR ANALYSIS CONCURS WITH YOUR VIEW THAT THE POTENTIAL EXISTS TO EXTRACT MEANINGFUL COST SAVINGS BY MERGING OUR ORGANISATIONS. HOWEVER, WE BELIEVE THAT YOU HAVE UNDERESTIMATED THE ONE-OFF COSTS OF ACHIEVING THE SAVINGS, THE ONGOING NET REVENUE LOSSES THAT WE ARE CONVINCED WILL RESULT FROM THE COMBINATION AND THE INHERENT RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MERGER. THE EFFECT IS THAT OUR ESTIMATES OF THE SUSTAINABLE NET FINANCIAL BENEFITS ARE FAR LOWER THAN YOURS.
IN THE LONGER TERM WE ALSO HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT THE GROWTH PROSPECTS OF THE MERGED ENTITY GIVEN THE HIGH MARKET SHARES WHICH WILL RESULT IN CERTAIN AREAS. THERE ARE CLEARLY BUSINESS RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH BEING BY FAR THE LARGEST BANKING GROUP IN SOUTH AFRICA.
WE CONCUR WITH YOUR EXPRESSED VIEW THAT IF A MERGER WERE TO TAKE PLACE THEN IT WOULD INEVITABLY REQUIRE THE UNTIMELY UNBUNDLING OR SALE OF OUR CONTROLLING INTEREST IN LIBERTY LIFE. THIS WOULD TERMINATE THE SIGNIFICANT SYNERGISTIC POTENTIAL OF STANBIC'S RELATIONSHIP WITH LIBERTY LIFE.
IN ADDITION, WE COULD NOT ACCEPT THE EARNINGS DILUTION THAT STANBIC
SHAREHOLDERS WOULD SUFFER IF A MERGER WERE TO OCCUR AT OR CLOSE TO MARKET VALUES.
ALL OF THE ABOVE HAS LED THE BOARD TO CONCLUDE THAT YOUR CURRENT PLAN WOULD NOT BE IN THE INTERESTS OF STANBIC SHAREHOLDERS.
FOR THE BOARD TO RECONSIDER ITS POSITION IT WOULD REQUIRE AN APPROPRIATE EXCHANGE RATIO WHICH COMPENSATES STANBIC SHAREHOLDERS FOR EARNINGS DILUTION AND MERGER RISK. AS AN ABSOLUTE MINIMUM WE WOULD REQUIRE THAT THE EARNINGS IMPACT OF THE TRANSACTION BE EQUALISED BETWEEN THE TWO SETS OF SHAREHOLDERS AND THAT OUR SHAREHOLDERS SUFFER NO EARNINGS DILUTION IN THE FIRST YEAR OF THE MERGER PRIOR TO ANY ASSUMED MERGER BENEFITS. IT IS THE CONSIDERED VIEW OF THE BOARD AND ITS FINANCIAL ADVISERS, J.P. MORGAN AND DEUTSCHE BANK, THAT ON THIS BASIS THE EXCHANGE RATIO MUST BE NO LESS FAVOURABLE TO STANBIC SHAREHOLDERS THAN 1 NEDCOR SHARE FOR 4.75 STANBIC SHARES. THIS RATIO WOULD NEED TO BE ADJUSTED FOR ANY UNBUNDLING OR SALE OF STANBIC ASSETS, WHICH MUST BE PURELY FOR THE ACCOUNT AND BENEFIT OF STANBIC SHAREHOLDERS. IT ALSO SPECIFICALLY EXCLUDES ANY FORM OF CONTROL PREMIUM, WHICH WOULD BE REQUIRED IF THE SUBSTANCE OF YOUR PROPOSAL PROVES TO BE A TAKEOVER RATHER THAN A TRUE MERGER OF EQUALS.
IF YOU ARE WILLING TO CHANGE YOUR PREVIOUS STANCE OF AN EXCHANGE RATIO AT MARKET VALUES AND ACCEPT THIS MINIMUM RATIO, WHICH MAY REQUIRE A CASH
COMPONENT, THERE ARE CRITICAL ADDITIONAL ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE RESOLVED. THE BULK OF THE PERCEIVED MERGER BENEFITS ARE BASED ON COMBINING COMMERCIAL BANKING BUSINESSES IN SOUTH AFRICA WHICH REPRESENT APPROXIMATELY 45% OF STANBIC'S EARNINGS. YOUR PLAN DOES NOT SUFFICIENTLY ADDRESS THE OTHER IMPORTANT COMPONENTS OF STANBIC'S BUSINESS. THESE INCLUDE:SCMB, WHICH WE CONSIDER TO BE AN EXTREMELY STRONG FRANCHISE THAT IS LIKELY TO BE SUBSTANTIALLY DAMAGED BY THE MERGER; AFRICA, WHERE THERE IS A MARKED DIFFERENCE IN OUR RESPECTIVE
STRATEGIES; STANDARD BANK LONDON, WHICH WE BELIEVE IS A BUSINESS WITH STRONG GROWTH POTENTIAL AND, AS MENTIONED ABOVE, LIBERTY LIFE. WE ARE ALSO CONCERNED ABOUT POTENTIAL VALUE LOSS FROM THE DILUTION OF THE STANDARD BANK BRAND. IN ADDITION YOU HAVE MADE NO SUBSTANTIVE PROPOSAL WITH REGARD TO SENIOR MANAGEMENT AND BOARD STRUCTURES.
ALTHOUGH YOU HAVE PERSONALLY EXPRESSED SOME CONFIDENCE IN OBTAINING COMPETITION TRIBUNAL AND OTHER REGULATORY APPROVALS, WE HAVE BEEN ADVISED THAT THE NATURE AND SIZE OF THIS TRANSACTION IS SUCH THAT THE PROCESS IS LIKELY TO BE OF UNCERTAIN OUTCOME. WE WOULD NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES CONSIDER EXPOSING STANBIC TO THE BUSINESS RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH AN UNACCEPTABLE DELAY IN RECEIVING REGULATORY APPROVALS.
WE BELIEVE THAT ANY FORM OF DUE DILIGENCE WILL INEVITABLY INVOLVE SHARING COMPETITIVE INFORMATION WHICH COULD PROVE DETRIMENTAL TO SHAREHOLDERS AND THEREFORE WOULD ONLY BE APPROPRIATE ONCE ALL OF THESE MATTERS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED."
ACCORDINGLY, SHAREHOLDERS ARE ADVISED TO EXERCISE CAUTION UNTIL A FURTHER ANNOUNCEMENT IS MADE. JOHANNESBURG 26 OCTOBER 1999

Share This Story